Fact check: False claim that Biden ordered the FBI search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate – USA TODAY
The claim: Biden ordered the FBI’s search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate
After a judge granted former President Donald Trump’s request for an independent review of records seized from his Mar-a-Lago estate, some social media users have claimed a phrase from the court ruling indicates President Joe Biden ordered the search.
A tweet shared to Instagram on Sept. 5 includes a screenshot of part of the court order from U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon. The order says the government informed Trump it will provide the FBI access to the records, ”as requested by the incumbent President.”
The tweet highlights that phrase, and the Instagram post’s caption reads, “Biden ordered the raid.” The post generated more than 1,000 likes.
Follow us on Facebook! Like our page to get updates throughout the day on our latest debunks
But the claim is baseless.
Biden did not order the FBI search, multiple legal experts told USA TODAY. And the quote referring to “the incumbent president” is not proof that he did: It’s from a letter the National Archives and Records Administration sent to Trump’s lawyer about 15 boxes of records the agency had retrieved from Mar-a-Lago in mid-January – seven months before the FBI search of the property.
USA TODAY reached out to the social media users who shared the claim for comment.
Court order does not show Biden ordered FBI search
Biden did not order the FBI’s August search, and the line in the court order referenced in the Instagram post does not indicate otherwise, Bradley Moss, a national security lawyer, told USA TODAY in an email.
Instead, the letter is referencing access to documents that were retrieved from Mar-a-Lago in January, long before the highly-publicized FBI search.
The phrase “as requested by an incumbent president” is a quote from a May 10 letter the head of the archives agency, Debra Steidel Wall, wrote to Trump’s lawyer, Evan Corcoran.
As USA TODAY previously reported, Trump stored records at Mar-a-Lago in violation of the Presidential Records Act, which requires the archives agency to manage all documents and communications related to a president or vice president’s official duties after a president leaves office. As a result, the archives agency retrieved 15 boxes of documents from Trump in January.
The archives agency notified the Justice Department of the boxes, which then asked Biden to permit the agency to grant the FBI access to the documents, according to the letter. The White House Counsel’s Office granted the request on April 11.
In the letter, Wall rejected Corcoran’s request to delay turning over the 15 boxes of to the FBI for review.
Fact check roundup: What’s true and what’s false about the FBI’s search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate
The full text of the court order – cropped out of the viral post – makes it clear this is the situation being referred to in the reference to Biden.
While the Presidential Records Act only allows for public access to presidential records five years after the end of a president’s tenure, Wall wrote that it also allows those records to be available to the incumbent executive branch if needed.
In other words, Biden gets to have access to Trump’s records if Biden attests that they contain information that the executive branch needs to do its work and the information isn’t available elsewhere, according to Kel McClanahan, a national security law expert at George Washington University.
Fact check: Pelosi and DePape struggle involved one hammer, not a ‘hammer fight,’ police say
“(The provision in the Presidential Records Act is the) exception to the rule that nobody gets access to presidential records for five years,” McClanahan said. “It’s why the FBI couldn’t get Trump’s records until Biden personally authorized them to.”
The Associated Press and PolitiFact debunked this claim.
An independent judge – not the president – authorized the FBI’s search
The Justice Department makes independent decisions on whether to conduct criminal investigations, and the president is not involved in this process, as USA TODAY previously reported.
Final approval to search Mar-a-Lago came from U.S. Magistrate Judge Bruce Reinhart.
The Justice Department submitted a search warrant application to Reinhart as part of a federal investigation into allegations that Trump unlawfully stored classified documents in his Mar-a-Lago estate.
Fact check: No evidence of a leaked call between Biden, FBI director before Mar-a-Lago search
Any official seeking a search warrant must present an affidavit of probable cause showing that a particular crime or crimes have been committed and that evidence will be located at a particular location, David Weinstein, former assistant U.S. attorney, told USA TODAY.
The judge decides whether they believe there is probable cause after reviewing the affidavit, he said. Reinhart found that probable cause existed to search and seize property at Trump’s estate and authorized the search warrant, as noted in the search warrant.
Our rating: False
Based on our research, we rate FALSE the claim that Biden ordered the FBI’s search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate. Biden did not authorize the FBI’s search; that approval came from Reinhart. The phrase in Cannon’s court order addresses how Biden granted the Justice Department’s request to permit the archives agency to give the FBI 15 boxes of presidential records it had retrieved from Trump’s Mar-a-Lago resort in mid-January. The phrase has nothing to do with the FBI’s August search.
Our fact-check sources:
- USA TODAY, Aug. 18, Fact check: No evidence of a leaked call between Biden, FBI director before Mar-a-Lago search
- Neama Rahmani, Oct. 13, Email exchange and phone interview with USA TODAY
- Bradley Moss, Oct. 13, Email exchange with USA TODAY
- Kenneth Mayer, Oct. 13, Email exchange with USA TODAY
- Kel McClanahan, Oct. 13, Email exchange with USA TODAY
- David Weinstein, Aug. 16, Phone interview with USA TODAY
- The Associated Press, Sept. 6, Judge’s order doesn’t show Biden ordered FBI search
- PolitiFact, Aug. 31, Document doesn’t prove Biden ‘lied’ about Mar-a-Lago probe
- USA TODAY, Sept. 5, Judge approves special master to review documents from Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate, pauses DOJ probe
- Factcheck.org, Aug. 31, Timeline of FBI Investigation of Trump’s Handling of Highly Classified Documents
- USA TODAY, Feb. 9, National Archives obtained 15 boxes of presidential records from Mar-a-Lago
- The National Archives and Records Administration, May 10, Letter to Evan Corcoran
- USA TODAY, Aug. 12, Read the FBI’s search warrant for Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago property
- United States District Court Southern District of Florida, accessed Oct. 28, Court order
- USA TODAY, Nov. 10, 2021, Trump claimed executive privilege to shield info from Jan. 6 committee. Here’s what that means
Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.
Our fact-check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook.
